Libertarians Are Wrong to Support an “Ellis Island” Immigration-Control System

Source: Future of Freedom Foundation
by Jacob G Hornberger

“On the issue of immigration, there are two completely different positions within the libertarian movement. One position favors a government-controlled, government-managed system in which federal officials centrally plan the numbers and characteristics of immigrants that will be permitted to enter the United States. The other position is commonly known as ‘open borders.’ This position is based on the principles of economic liberty and the free market. … Some libertarians attempt to ‘straddle the fence’ by endorsing what they call an ‘Ellis Island’ type of immigration-control system. … it’s not freedom — not genuine freedom. That’s a problem for libertarians, who purport to favor freedom, especially economic liberty and free-market principles.” (06/16/26)

https://www.fff.org/2026/06/16/libertarians-are-wrong-to-support-an-ellis-island-immigration-control-system/