A Simple Defense of Nationwide Injunctions

Source: The Volokh Conspiracy
by Ilya Somin

“The main issue addressed in yesterday’s birthright citizenship oral argument before the Supreme Court was whether federal courts should have the power to issue nationwide injunctions against illegal government policies, as opposed to injunctions limited to the parties to the case, or perhaps to a particular state or local government. As I see it, there is a simple, but powerful reason why courts must have the power to issue such injunctions, at least in some cases. In many situations, there is no other way to stop widespread illegality, especially that perpetrated by the federal government. Nationwide wrongs require a nationwide remedy.” (05/16/25)

https://reason.com/volokh/2025/05/16/a-simple-defense-of-nationwide-injunctions/