American Jews Have Long Questioned Zionism

Source: Common Dreams
by Marty Blatt & Marjorie Feld

“As historians and as anti-Zionist Jews active in our communities, we know that unqualified support for Israel has been widespread among American Jews, built on the idea that only Israel could prevent another Holocaust and keep Jews safe. But crucially, there has never been a complete pro-Zionist ‘consensus.’ What we understand is that there has always been a small, vocal, articulate American Jewish minority (many with direct ties to the devastation of the Holocaust) who fundamentally questioned the role of Zionism and Israel in American Jewish life and asserted that Zionism and democratic ideals are incompatible. Our own lives and research agendas illuminate that for over a century, since the beginning of the modern Zionist movement with Theodor Herzl in 1897, some American Jews have drawn attention to the brutality and racism inherent in the modern Zionist project.” (09/23/24)

https://www.commondreams.org/opinion/american-jews-zionism